I didn’t think you did, but that’s okay. I joined a FB group as was suggested, and someone in there told me that a Windows update was the problem. So I uninstalled the update shown in my screenshot above, restarted my computer, and tried again. This time, the print then cut worked, and I can upload my sticker sheets from Photoshop into Design Space no problem and print. The cuts are now beautiful and customer ready. I feel like 100 pounds have been lifted.
I bought a bunch of different planners, including Erin Condren, just to get the sizes I needed for my stickers. So when the brand new Cricut wasn’t working, I started to get really stressed out and worried that I screwed up. Now that it’s fixed, it’s business time.